WatchmenThis review probably contains spoilers.
I want to start by saying that I am a fan of
Watchmen the comic. The opinions I've formed are from a fan's perspective. I don't know how this movie works as a standalone flick, and I don't know if people who've never heard of the comics will like it. It's impossible for me to look at the film objectively, or as anyone who isn't the huge fan that I am.
I loved this movie. Maybe it's unfair, because I went into this movie prepared to love it, and it would've taken a pretty serious disaster to convince me not to. But I don’t really care about that because, luckily, Snyder and company made exactly the kind of
Watchmen movie I wanted to see. It wasn't perfect and I'll move on to specifics in a second, but I want to be absolutely clear up front: I loved this movie and can't wait to see it again. I am a fan who didn't go into the movie prepared to hate it. I think that makes me the perfect audience for this movie. Which is cool, because it means that Zach Snyder managed to get a shitload of money to make a movie that was directly targeted for people like me.
It'll be easiest to explain how I like this movie, and why I'm the perfect fan for this movie, by talking about the opening credits. If you haven't seen it yet, the opening credits features shot after shot of various stages in this alternate history, to really set up the world in which the movie takes place. There's shots of the Minutemen fighting crime and posing for pictures in the 40s. Shots of the original Silk Spectre retiring. Shots of The Comedian and Dr. Manhattan fighting in Vietnam. Shots of Dollar Bill's unfortunate death, shots of Silhouette and her controversially sexy lesbian lifestyle. Shots of The Comedian shooting JFK. No words, just a moving visual timeline that spans over forty years. We see the transition of carefree, tabloid-craving celebrity superheroes of the 40s to a darker, more realistic breed of hero. Watching the opening credits, my immediate thought was "If they do this for the entire movie, I'd be okay with that. If they did this for the full two hours and forty-three minutes, I would be totally fucking fine with that." Because, Look- it's the Comedian on screen. That's exactly what he's supposed to look like. And there's Hollis Mason publishing Under the Hood. That's exactly what HE'S supposed to look like. It's all of these characters I love, brought to life and doing exactly what they're supposed to be doing. And that's what I wanted. I already know why the Comedian's my favorite character. Now I want to watch him running around, doing what he does.
To stop myself from making a completely fawning review, I'll admit there were things I didn't like. Malin Ackerman's performance was the weakest part of the movie. Maybe I'm biased, because I never totally cared about Silk Spectre II, anyway, so it's possible that I'd be bored regardless of who played the part. But I don't think that's the case. I think she's just an average actress playing a wooden, underdeveloped character. She certainly gets naked, and I do appreciate that, but she brings nothing to the table. I think the scenes between Rorschach and the psychiatrist were unfortunately cut short and that their particular dynamic was handled poorly. There are some lines that I wish made it to the screen. I also thought Lex and Tim were annoying as shit, but I still think Jurassic Park is an awesome movie. If you're looking for flaws, you'll find them.
If I'm thinking about important things that I missed, it would be Hollis Mason's death. In the comic, this was important to me because it had nothing to do with superheroes or conspiracies or nuclear war. It was just a very horrible, very unfortunate and very real freak occurrence. It was a way of saying "Yeah, superheroes are so burdened and tortured and they've got it so tough but, you know what? It's tough all over. Terrible things happen to good people for no reason all the time. This is our world." I always thought that was really effective. But, again, it's not something that I'm going to crucify this movie for leaving out, because I love all that they left in.
Apart from Malin, I don't have a single complaint about the casting. Matthew Goode is a standout to me right now, not because he was better than anyone else, but because, in my mind, he had the hardest task. Ozymandias just isn't an exciting character. Until the end of the comic, he just comes off as this tedious, yuppy sellout. In the movie, he's the one character who I feel became more realized as a result of the performance. Goode really brought out the kind of colossal disconnect and loneliness that could only accompany the World's Smartest Man. Billy Crudup was a brilliant and inspiring choice, but I've been such a fan of his for years that it didn't even matter if he sucked, I would've loved it anyway. Jackie Earle Haley was another brilliant choice and, when he removes his mask at the end, it was the closest I'd come to crying in probably thirteen years. And I don't know how it happened, but Patrick Wilson managed to figure out what voice I was picturing in my head when I read Dan Drieberg's parts, and he used it in the film. As soon as I heard him speak, I thought "Yeah, that's how he sounds...
How did you do that?"
And, of course, The Comedian. Most people I've talked to, about both the comic and the movie, point to Rorschach as their favorite character. That's understandable, but my favorite character is and always has been The Comedian, because he's just so real. Sure, you want your superheroes to be like Nite Owl II, a smart guy who follows the rules and just wants to help people, and you wish you had superheroes like Rorschach, people who are committed and uncompromising and dependable. But, here in real life, you'd get a world of Comedians. Power corrupts, and who has more power than a superhero/government-sanctioned assassin? The Comedian is what happens when you give someone unfiltered access to do whatever is necessary in the interest of serving his country. He's a patriot and he's a monster, and it's ugly but it's real. I went into this movie watching Jeffrey Dean Morgan more closely than any of the other actors, and I was not disappointed. A fucking smirking alpha male beast. He played the complex and burdened character to perfection, and now I'm kind of a little bit gay for him.
When it comes to reviewing this movie, for me it's easier to address the complaints I've heard from other fans and fan boys. I've heard and read a lot of responses from superfans who hated this movie. They can point to specific scenes that were in their minds wrongfully left out. A skipped panel is looked upon as a grievous sacrilege, and they use every example of an altered scene as reason enough to condemn the whole movie. You've read reviews like this; "They left out scene [x] or shortened this speech, which RUINS THE ENTIRE MOVIE." And yes, if your ability to appreciate this movie hinges on whether or not the Comedian will ever wear his gimp mask, than you will have ample reason to hate it. Because that's what you want to do. At the risk of sounding presumptuous and insulting, I get the idea that the fans who didn't like this movie went into it prepared to hate it. They called it "unfilmable" in advance and sat in the theater, already snarling, and taking mental notes every time a line was skipped or a fight scene was extended. They didn't like the new ending, despite the fact that it kept the spirit of the original ending while also being monumentally less retarded. That's an improvement in my book. It just seems strange to me that people can say "Silk Spectre said Dr. Manhattan's line at the end and it DESTROYED THE ENTIRE FUCKING MOVIE," or "Dr. Manhattan didn't catch Silk and Nite Owl fucking and I ALMOST KILLED MYSELF."
Yes, the movie was more violent and the fight scenes were longer than they were in the comic. You know why I like that? Because action scenes in comics are, almost without exception, boring as shit. They can look beautiful, sometimes, but if I ever got a comic that was 25 pages of explosions and wordless fighting, I'd be bored. This isn't specific to
Watchmen, either. Frank Miller's
Dark Knight Returns is one of my all time favorite comics, but I don't like it because of Batman's fight with the giant king mutant freak. I don't like it for the Superman/Batman battle at the end. I like it for just about everything else. And Bendis, one of my favorite comics writers working today, can't write battle scenes for shit, and that's fine. When I think of
Secret War, I don't think about the big river fight at the end, I think about the brilliant way the story was told, the complex position Nick Fury was forced to take and, like always, Bendis' unmatched knack for crafting the perfect dialogue for Spider-man.
So, sure,
Watchmen the movie had extended fight scenes. Wanna know why? Because fight scenes in movies are cooler than fight scenes in comics. There's been a trend in movies for that really close up, gritty Bourne-style fighting. It's cool, I guess, and probably realistic, but I can rarely tell what's even going on.
Watchmen didn't take that approach, and had some of the coolest fight choreography I've seen in a while. Watch this movie again. Watch the scene where Rorschach is fighting off a ton of cops, and tell me that isn't some of the coolest looking shit you've ever seen. So intricate, so fast, so much going on. Really impressive stuff. That fight isn't anywhere near as impressive in the comics and, likewise, Alan Moore's judicious use of violence in the comic is more effective than it would've been in the movie. Comics and movies are different, and each used their inherent possibilities to their advantage. This has been my first lesson in "Things that Are Different from Other Things." Test Tuesday.
I think the difference between me and these fan boys is that I went into the theater knowing that my favorite part of the comic wasn't going to be included. You know what my absolute favorite part was? The excerpts from Under the Hood. Without a doubt. I love how much of Hollis' character comes through, I love how much you can learn about the time period by reading his thoughts. I wish they sold a fully realized version of that fake autobiography so I can read it all, because it just seemed so damn charming and interesting. I knew there wasn't going to be a portion of the movie dedicated to old Hollis reading full chapters of his book, and I was okay with that. None of those parts were in the movie, and, hey, I didn’t lose my shit over it. The important parts of
Watchmen remained intact, and that's what matters. If I really want to experience parts of the comic that I liked that didn't make it to the movie, I could just, you know, read the comic again.
The people who point out the small reasons to hate
Watchmen, the nitpicky things, I honestly don't know what kind of movie they wanted to watch. Truly. I have no idea how to put myself in their heads. They wanted, I suppose, a film version that was identical to the comic version. This, no matter what anyone says, is impossible. Impossible. That's not saying that it's impossible to make a good comics movie, or a good
Watchmen movie, just that it's by definition impossible to film a movie that will yield the exact same experience as the comic on which it's based. And even if they could, why would I want a movie that's exactly like the comic?
I already
have the comic.
That's, I suppose, the thesis I want to get out to all of the fanboys who hated the movie. Nothing is being taken from you. Nothing is being replaced. You can still say the comic was better. You can even still read the comic. Hell, you can even still walk around with that smug sense of superiority if you want. I know I'm still going to read the comic, because I love it. And I'll watch the movie again because, though it's different, I love that, too.
I wanted something new. Something that still spoke to the heart of
Watchmen, but still something new. I wanted to see these characters come to life and say the words they're supposed to say and do the things they're supposed to do. And that's what I kept thinking in the theater. Dan would walk down the street and give Kovacs an odd look, or the Comedian would light a cigar and grin, or Dr. Manhattan would look perpetually distracted, (junk a-flopping), and I just thought "Yes, that's what's supposed to happen. That's what they're supposed to look like, and that's what they're supposed to do."